
Beyond the M25: what Chester and the North taught us about growing GoodtoGive
October 21, 2026
Beyond the M25: what Chester and the North taught us about growing GoodtoGive
October 21, 2026December is one of the busiest months in the church calendar, and it’s when Gift Aid record keeping is most likely to slip. There’s the Christmas programme, the Christmas Day service, Watchnight, extra visitors through the doors, and special offerings on top of the usual tithes and offerings.
Everyone is busy, and writing things down carefully can slip down the list. That’s understandable. But the Gift Aid claim in the new year is much easier when December’s giving was recorded at the time.
Here are five common slip-ups, and a simple fix for each. Want to talk them through with our team? Join our live online webinar, Make Christmas Giving Easier, on 3 December.
At a Glance: The Five Mistakes
Five Gift Aid Record-keeping Mistakes & How to Fix Them
1. Counting the money but not writing down who gave it
The offering is counted, bagged and banked, and everyone heads home. But to include a donation in a Gift Aid claim, you generally need to know who gave it, and names are very hard to remember a few weeks later. HMRC’s guidance on Gift Aid declarations sets out the donor details a declaration must include.
Try this: Ask people to write their name on their envelope or a donation slip on the day, and have someone note down the names as the money is counted.
2. Assuming a Gift Aid declaration is already on file
“I’m sure Sister Brown signed one years ago.” It’s easy to believe, especially with long-standing members. But thinking a declaration exists isn’t the same as having it.
Try this: Check before you include someone’s donations. If one is missing, ask them to complete one. In many cases a donor can still do this after they’ve given, so it’s worth asking sooner rather than later. See HMRC’s guidance on backdating Gift Aid declarations. If you’d like help keeping declarations matched to donations, see our Gift Aid management service.
3. Mixing donations you can link to a person with ones you can’t
Loose cash from the plate often ends up in the same pile as donations with a name and a declaration behind them. That makes it hard to see what’s ready to claim.
Try this: Keep donations you can link to a named person separate from the rest. Small cash and contactless donations of £30 or less can sometimes be claimed under the Gift Aid Small Donations Scheme, which has its own conditions, so check these on gov.uk first.
4. Leaving the record half-finished
A note that says “£140 offering” with no date, service or name is hard to use in January. Nobody remembers which Sunday it was.
Try this: Use one simple sheet with the same columns every time, so nothing gets missed. (The checklist below gives you the columns.)
5. Rebuilding December from memory in January
By the new year, the busy weeks have blurred together. Volunteers have moved on, notes have gone missing, and people are guessing.
Try this: Write it down while the service is still fresh, even if it’s only a few lines. Decide before the first collection who owns the record. For more on this, read how volunteers can boost your charity’s Gift Aid claims.
What To Write Down on The Day: A Simple Gift Aid Record Checklist
Keep it simple. For each donation, note:
- Who gave it
- How they gave it (cash, card or bank transfer)
- The date and the amount
- Whether a Gift Aid declaration is already on file
Then note who wrote it down, and where that record is kept. Tithes and offerings are no different from any other donation here. For a wider look at good records, see our guide to accurate record keeping.
Free live webinar
Make Christmas Giving Easier
Getting these habits in place before the busy weeks start makes the new year far less stressful.
For church treasurers, administrators, trustees and anyone who looks after giving at a church or charity. You don’t need to be a GoodtoGive client to attend.
We’ll cover
You’ll also have the chance to ask questions, and to check how your own giving setup compares. Monique and Meghna from our team will take you through it step by step.
Register for the webinar →Can’t make it live? Register anyway and tell us what you’d like covered. We’ll share a summary of the session.
Frequently Asked Questions
For each donation, note who gave it, how they gave it (cash, card or bank transfer), the date and the amount, and whether a Gift Aid declaration is already on file. Then note who wrote it down and where the record is kept.
In many cases, yes, so if a declaration is missing it’s worth asking sooner rather than later. HMRC’s guidance on Gift Aid declarations explains how declarations can be backdated.
Small cash and contactless donations of £30 or less can sometimes be claimed under the Gift Aid Small Donations Scheme. It has its own conditions, so check these on gov.uk first, and keep these donations separate from ones you can link to a named donor.
Decide before the first collection who owns the record, and agree where it will be kept. Writing a few lines while the service is still fresh saves rebuilding December from memory in January.

